placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich is 81 years old at the time of the interview and lives in the northwestern part of Switzerland. Her husband, seven years older than she is, recently moved into a nursing home. He was diagnosed with dementia ten years ago, however, Mrs. Hürsch believes that the first signs of the disease appeared ten years before the diagnosis. Mrs. Hürsch cares for her husband with the help of their four children. Two of the children, Mr. Hürsch (age 51) and Mrs. Colombo-Hürsch (age 52), participated in the interview. Despite having constant care, a period of increased aggressivity a few years ago added additional stress on Mrs. Hürsch. Sending her husband to the day program two to three times a week as well as taking a vacation bed for a few days was essential to provide more complete breaks from care. Transferring her husband to a nursing home was an emotionally difficult step for Mrs. Hürsch.

AUDIO

The theory that music is the best therapy against dementia proved to be inapplicable in the case of her husband, who had played music continuously for 70 years, says Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich.

She had heard on the radio that music is the best therapy against dementia, says Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich. In the case of her husband, though, who was exceptionally musical and had played music continuously for 70 years, this theory proved to be inapplicable.

Video Interview

TRANSCRIPT

...

Other experiences by Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich is 81 years old at the time of the interview and lives in the northwestern part of Switzerland. Her husband, seven years older than she is, recently moved into a nursing home. He was diagnosed with dementia ten years ago, however, Mrs. Hürsch believes that the first signs of the disease appeared ten years before the diagnosis. Mrs. Hürsch cares for her husband with the help of their four children. Two of the children, Mr. Hürsch (age 51) and Mrs. Colombo-Hürsch (age 52), participated in the interview. Despite having constant care, a period of increased aggressivity a few years ago added additional stress on Mrs. Hürsch. Sending her husband to the day program two to three times a week as well as taking a vacation bed for a few days was essential to provide more complete breaks from care. Transferring her husband to a nursing home was an emotionally difficult step for Mrs. Hürsch.

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

The theory that music is the best therapy against dementia proved to be inapplicable in the case of her husband, who had played music continuously for 70 years, says Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich.

She had heard on the radio that music is the best therapy against dementia, says Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich. In the case of her husband, though, who was exceptionally musical and had played music continuously for 70 years, this theory proved to be inapplicable.

What is dementia?

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

It was only after her husband moved into a nursing home that Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich fully realized how much she had needed care at home.

It was only after her husband moved into a nursing home that Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich fully realized how much she had needed care at home.

What is dementia care?

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

The transition in communication is not trivial for Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich because habitual ways of relaying information or having discussions must be totally abandoned.

The transition in communication is not trivial for Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich because habitual ways of relaying information or having discussions must be totally abandoned. For example, she can no longer simply ask her husband questions to engage him in conversation. Often, trying to offer a well-intentioned explanation elicits an angry reaction.

Four levels of communication of the caregivers

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Her husband tried to conceal his confusion and forgetfulness, says Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich. The diagnosis finally served as an "explanation" for the family.

Her husband's confusion and forgetfulness were noticed by the family long before he received a diagnosis, Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich relates. Her husband tried to conceal his difficulties. The diagnosis finally served as an "explanation" for the family.

Diagnosis

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

How Mr. Hürsch is handling the disease and how much of his disability he perceives is not clear to the family.

How Mr. Hürsch is handling the disease and how much of his disability he perceives is not clear to the family. His self-expression "If you only knew what it looks like in my head", which expresses frustration and despair, is contrasted by the assumption of his relatives that he is less and less able to reflect on himself. It is also possible that Mr. Hürsch has resigned himself to the illness, his daughter speculates.

What is dementia?

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich is concerned about how much her husband still understands.

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich is concerned about how much her husband still understands. Although she shares the view of her children that he lost a significant amount of mental capacity, she assumes that some awareness is available to him. Not even the "top professor" is able to come to grips with the complexity of the brain.

What is dementia?

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Dementia is not a physical disease like cancer that destroys the body, says Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich. She identifies suffering caused by the disease as existing on a different level.

Dementia is not a physical disease like cancer that destroys the body, says Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich. She identifies suffering caused by the disease as existing on another level. Even after the person with the disease is significantly cognitively impaired, the condition continues for a long time. Those who interact with the dementia patient become entangled in moral dilemmas, which causes emotional suffering.

What is dementia?

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Mrs. Hürsch’s family and doctors had different assessments of whether he could still drive safely.

Mr. Hürsch’s family and doctors had different assessments of whether he could still drive safely. Eventually, Mr. Hürsch surrendered his driving license himself. According to his son, a key factor was that Mr. Hürsch was able to decide the timing for himself rather than feel the doctor was dictating it.

Diagnosis

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Mrs. Hürsch and her daughter were disappointed with the opinion of the doctor, who still felt that Mr. Hürsch was safe to drive.

Mrs. Hürsch, together with her daughter, Mrs. Colombo-Hürsch, initiated an assessment of Mr. Hürsh’s driving ability because they considered him to be a possible danger on the road. They were disappointed with the opinion of the doctor, who still felt that Mr. Hürsch could drive safely.

Diagnosis

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich's experience with the Spitex staff and the care team at the daycare center has been consistently positive. The external support eased the situation for her at home.

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich's experience with the Spitex staff and the care team at the daycare center has been consistently positive. The external support eased the situation for her at home.

What helps? - Caregivers' perspective

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

The nursing home is the "wrong place to try to save money," the Hürsch family unanimously concludes. Every person who enters a nursing home deserves good care.

The nursing home is the "wrong place to save money," the Hürsch family unanimously concludes. Every person who enters a nursing home deserves good care.

What helps? - Caregivers' perspective

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich's search for a home for her husband took place under great pressure.

Mrs. Hürsch-Dietrich's search for a home for her husband was carried out under great pressure. Since his dementia was considered far advanced and not treatable, he had to leave the clinic they had found. Mrs. Hürsch's children, together with the clinic's social services, helped her find a new care facility. However, the possible options were limited and often too far away, her daughter notes.

At home or in a nursing home?

Dementia

placeholder

Frau Hürsch-Dietrich, Herr Hürsch und Frau Colombo-Hürsch

For Mr. Hürsch and Mrs. Colombo-Hürsch, it was not easy to witness how their mother was affected by being cared for at home. Nevertheless, they went along with their mother’s preference instead of transferring her to a home. They took away the burden of finding a home.

It was not easy for Mr. Hürsch and Mrs. Colombo-Hürsch to see how their mother was affected by being cared for at home. Nevertheless, they went along with their mother instead of transferring her to a home. They took away the burden of finding a home.

At home or in a nursing home?

Dementia

View all experiences

© 2000-2021, All Rights Reserved